Highline Community College Library Reference Department
Telling the Difference:
Scholarly Journals and Popular Magazines


Introduction

Definitions

Audience

Author(s)

Peer Reviewed

Article Length

Bibliographies

Other Clues

Conclusion


Other Clues in Telling the Difference

We have already looked at how scholarly journals and popular magazines are different from
 each other in terms of who their audience is and who writes for them, whether it is peer
 reviewed, the length of the articles, and whether they have a bibliography.

Here are a few other clues to help you tell the difference.

 

The covers of journals tend to be plain.  Journals articles are mostly text, with no or few pictures or illustrations.  There often will be charts, graphs, or tables accompanying the article. 

Appearance  

Magazine covers are a lot flashier, with colorful pictures and catchy phrases, designed to catch the eye of a potential buyer. Magazine articles usually have colorful photographs.
 




Journals almost never have advertising.


Advertising  


Magazines have lots of advertising.  It's one of the ways that magazines make money, by selling space to advertisers.  It's also one of the easiest ways to tell magazines and journals apart.

 

Journal articles are usually very structured.  Research articles especially follow a pattern of having these components:

  • Abstract
  • Literature review
  • Methodology
  • Results
  • Conclusion or Discussion
  • Bibliography
 


Article Structure

 


 

 

Magazine articles don't follow any particular structure.  They can follow a variety of structures in how they are written.

       previous page  next page 

Library Home    |    Research Resources    |    Library Information    |    Library Services    |    Library Intranet


Highline Community College Library

P.O. Box 98000 Des Moines, WA 98198-9800  
(206)  878-3710 x3234


Highline Library Reference Department
refhelp@highline.edu

last updated 15 Apr 2008
 

HCC Computing Resources Appropriate Use Policy


Federal Government
Documents Depository